2001 - "Circle"
Tracklist:
Limits 4-37 (Huigen)
Autumn 7-22 (Koopman)
November 2-56 (Heijboer)
Port-Voyage of the Soul 7-09 (Heijboer)
Gigolo 6-47 (Koopman)
Moving In Circles 5-21 (Huigen)
The Birthday Party 6-09 (Heijboer)
One-track Mind 6:40 (Huigen)
Chateau Jam 8-38 (Cliffhanger)
Cliffhanger was in the status of "disbanded" during a surprisingly
short period of time - just about
a year. For all I remember, these guys reunited already in the first half of
1999 and shortly after that
event they announced the next Cliffhanger album saying of it that, being crafted
in the vein of their
debut album, it will be as strong as "Cold Steel". While I really
consider the "Cold Steel" album
almost a masterpiece, I still pick the second Cliffhanger album as their best in
all senses. I think,
the band members have been in a hurry to announce the following album as a
proper part of their
cliff-hanger-discography, as while this new one is slightly better than their
more than three years
standing previous album, both the first Cliffhanger albums surpass
"Circle" in many respects.
This time all the good-to-excellent tracks are concentrated in the middle of the
album. More precisely,
these are tracks 4 to 8 and at least three of them were composed and performed
in Cliffhanger's best
traditions. The weakest of these best (huh!) compositions is an instrumental
one. Actually this is an
excellent, totally keyboard-driven piece with cascades of variegated
arrangements, speedy solos and
tasteful passages - all done masterly to the accompaniment of a diverse and
powerful, always tight
rhythm-section. The major imperfection here is more than just the lack of
guitar. The track sounds as if
Cliffhanger are just a (wonderful keyboard) trio, but not a quartet. Now it's
time to talk about the album's
real weak points (i.e. compositions). First of all I am very disappointed by the
leading track, on which
Reine's singing is as simple as his own semi-acoustic rhythm guitar chords, to
the accompaniment of
which he mostly sings here, as the instrumental 'help' from the direction of his
bandmates is too inert to
improve it (is this a potential hit since the most accessible song with quite an
obtrusive refrains opens
the album?). The second song is, maybe, a bit better, though both of them were
created the way
Cliffhanger never did before. The third track is a very simple instrumental, and
the closing ninth track,
which is also instrumental, has a few more or less interesting episodes. (Hey,
Gijs, where have you lost
your wonderful "side-long", epic, thoughtful and complex
compositions?) Please note: there are too
many unvocal tracks on the two last Cliffhanger albums and each of them contain
just one really decent
instrumental, whereas all others were as if played to reach the usual time
standards. Again, as if
following "The Mirror Site" album's scheme of contents, almost a half
of materials featured in "Circle"
is nothing if not examples of Neo. Thus, presently the name of the band doesn't
correspondent to the
'classic' sense of a cliff-hanger. Though, bearing in mind that the so called
soap operas are the same
cliff-hangers for lots of Earthly people, too, then Cliffhanger can be the
cliff-hanger at least within
Neo Progressive. But if the guys were brave enough to release a version of
"Circle" that would be
shorter than their traditional "56 to 60 min" (about 45 min without at
least the three first tracks that
are the weakest), then we could seriously talk on the theme "Cliffhanger
are back to their roots" and
give an excellent rating to "Circle". As for this album as it is,
looking back at "Mirror Site" I would
name it "The Fool Circle".
Cliffhnager
VM. June 15, 2001