2000 - "Collector's Sedition"
(69 min, 'Numavox')
Tracklist:
1. Am Juengsten Toge 2:28
2. On the Air 4:44
3. The Sentinel 7:33
4. The Navigator 5:11
5. No More Time For Love 4:40
6. Song du Jour 5:39
7. Red Money 4:32
8. Handsight 6:13
9. The Man With an Iron Heart 5:11
10. As It Should Be 4:56
11. At Every Turn 3:26
12. Safe Alone 4:52
13. Cold Grey Morning 4:45
14. The Dragon 5:42
All tracks by Kerry Livgren,
except: 6 - by K. & J. Livgren,
& 14 - by Adams, K. Livgren.
Line-up:
Kerry Livgren - electric, acoustic, & bass guitars;
keyboards
Yetsper Danteetsper - drums & percussion
Jake Livgren - vocals
(on all songs, except 2, 7, 9, 13, & 14)
Guest vocalists:
Kreg Hoover (on 9 & 13)
Don & Sam Billen (2)
Darren Rogers (7)
Jason Beddoe (14)
Recorded, mixed, & produced
by Kerry Livgren at "GrandyZine
Recording Co.", Berryton, KS.
The Album.
While before I really liked only both of the instrumental-based albums by Kerry, "One of Several Possible Musiks" and "Odyssey Into the Mind's Eye", "Collector's Sedition" has become the only vocal-based album by him that I really like as well. I would rate it as an absolute masterpiece, as well as both of the aforementioned albums, if only Red Money and Safe Alone (tracks 7 & 12), both of which are just merely good Hard Rock songs, would not have been included here. Above all, it's because of all the other compositions that are presented on "Collector's Sedition" are definitely progressive. (So, I will listen to the 60-minute 'version' of this 70-minute album.) As well as the solo creation of Kerry Livgren in general, stylistically, "Collector Sedition" is quite a motley album. Though of course, the choice of stylistics can never hinder a true artist from creating a masterpiece, regardless of whether a chosen stylistics would be of a unified or miscellaneous character. The presence of rather dark arrangements on a few of the tracks here, along with Jake's dramatic singing, is probably the only major difference between this and all of the other vocal-based albums by Kerry Livgren. Song du Jour and The Man With an Iron Heart (tracks 6 & 9) are excellent songs. The music that is featured on both of them represents an original and effective blend of Classic Hard- and Art-Rock. While all ten of the remaining tracks on the album (1 to 5, 7, 8, 10, 11, 13, & 14) are, in my honest opinion, real masterworks. The Navigator (4) is an outstanding Classic Art-Rock ballad, which, in some ways, reminds me of a really undying Dust In the Wind. (By the way, the lyrical concept of the everlasting flight of that Dust In the Wind is close to my Weltanschauung, though officially, I am an Orthodox Christian.) On The Navigator however, the passages of acoustic guitar interplay with solos of bass guitar and, closer to the end of the song, with the fluid solos of electric guitar. Here, Jake Livgren's singing has a slight folksy feel to it. In my view, Jake is undoubtedly the best vocalist on this album. I really like his voice and his way of singing, both of which are original, unlike those of most (if not all) of the other Kerry Livgren / AD vocalists. At Every Turn (11) is another Classic Art-Rock ballad on the album, though it is of a different character than that which I depicted previously. At Every Turn contains also elements of Classical Music. The arrangements here consist of diverse and, at the same time, beautiful interplay between the violin-like passages of synthesizer and those of acoustic guitar. Also, apart from Jake's lead vocals, it features a female choir. This is one of the two tracks on the album that were performed without the rhythm section. No More Time For Love and Cold Grey Morning (5 & 13) are both about Classic Symphonic Art-Rock with a healthy dose of elements of a strong, diverse, and progressive Hard Rock. The kaleidoscopic changes of musical dimensions are hallmarks of both of these songs. Apart from the solos and riffs of electric and bass guitars, solos and passages of synthesizers, Hammond organ, and piano, and the parts of drums, all of which are present almost everywhere on the album, the first of them features also the solos of harmonica. The following five compositions: Am Juengsten Toge, On the Air, Handsight, As It Should Be, and The Dragon (1, 2, 8, 10, & 14), are brilliant by all means. Structurally, one of the two instrumental pieces on the album, As It Should Be (10), is in many ways close to tracks 5 & 13, depicted above, though the arrangements are here certainly more diverse than those on No More Time For Love and Cold Grey Morning. Furthermore, this piece contains, in addition, elements of Classical Music created with the fanfare-, brass-, and vibraphone-like solos of synthesizers. Also, a few of the flute-like solos and those of acoustic guitar are here in the vein of the music of East. Another instrumental piece, Am Juengsten Toge (1), is about a pure Classical Music. It consists of continuously
listening to Jake's singing here, I had the impression that I was hearing some wandering minstrel-knight. The Sentinel is a Progressive Rock pearl of rare originality.
Summary.
Well, all the albums by Kerry Livgren (of course, not counting remakes, compilations, and live albums) are finally reviewed on these pages. A great man, a great composer and musician, and a great creation, indeed. (Apart from interviewing Kerry, I also read his book titled "Seeds of Change" - same as his first solo album.) The contribution that Kerry made to the Progressive Rock movement (counting his work with Kansas, of course) is really invaluable. Many of his songs are real classics for the future, though some of them, such as still the same Dust In the Wind, became a classic immediately after they were released. However, I regret that Kerry quit Kansas once again. In my honest opinion, he should never forget the band that his best works were created within the precincts of (whatever one may say). By the way, most of the best ten compositions of "Collector's Sedition" have episodes that remind me of Kansas both vocally and instrumentally. Taken together, these songs last about 50 minutes. If Kerry would have released them along with his old friends and band-mates (as it was in the case of "Somewhere To Elsewhere"), I would've been a bit happier.
VM. September 20, 2002
Related Links:
Kerry Livgren web-site & online store: http://www.numavox.com/