Porcupine Tree (UK) - 1995 - "The Sky Moves Sideways"
The only real "clone" album I know is "Somewhere but Yesterday" by Xitizen Cain
see the review). "The Sky Moves Sideways" released by the heroes of this material
few years ago on "Delerium" label is another more or less successfull attempt
to make a clone. What's more, Steven Wilson & Co made even an "improved clone"
of the legendary Pink Floyd's "Wish You Were Here" (1975), because Steven's work
contains more really "progressive" arrangements, plus a portion of his own (already
familiar since 1993) originality. Slow (less gloomy, though), very Floydian
music with typical Gilmoresque grave guitar solos have a prominent role on the
two-thirds of the album's playing time. Fortunately, Steven decided to include in this album
12-minute single Moonloop, one of the best and original compositions he ever
made. This piece will blow up somewhere in the middle of this peaceful, on the whole,
and pensive landscape. Moonloop is the only separate composition here, not sounding like "Wish
You Were Here" at all! As a result, I can rate this album only as almost a
clone, yet excellent. However, the level of complexity on the clone-album "Somewhere
but Yesterday" is higher than here, therefore the rating (five, but not six "stars") for
The Sky Moves Sideways conforms to the reality. As to the term "clone", please
read the detailed review on Ozrics' "Strangeitudes".
Pursuit - 2006 - "Quest"
Pursuit is a three-piece from the American state of Iowa comprising Andrew Zuehlke on vocals, Dan Wolfe on guitars and keyboards and John Sebring on drums and backing vocals. "Quest", which is their first official release, is a mixed bag where straightforward AOR and metal numbers adjoin those leaning towards heavy symphonic progressive, most of such resembling Kansas in style. Among the 12 tracks, there also are two that approach the best examples of contemporary prog-metal, but nevertheless, the number of simple songs noticeably exceeds that of those interesting from a progressive standpoint. It doesn't manage without certain drawbacks in the performance department either. The drummer is strongly inferior to his partners, playing well only within the plain movements, but failing each time the music gets a more complicated shape. I can't remember the last time I heard such an inconsistent album as this.